1st Team All League
| Aubrey Kennedy | Aurora |
| Ava Farnham | Revere |
| Gabriella Melin | Kent |
| Kate Archer | Tallmadge |
| Kayla Smith | Revere |
| Phoebe Lutzko | Highland |
| Jeanie Barzellato | Kent |
| Kathryn Ennemoser | Kent |
| Bella Richards | Tallmadge |
| Katie Critchett | Highland |
| Aleksandra Koval | Highland |
| Ollie Salgado | Aurora |
| Coco Golden | Kent |
| Annabelle Reece | Aurora |
| Julia Grandon | Revere |
| Kelsey Krizansky | Aurora |
| Championship Coach | Corey Spicer | Roosevelt | |
| Swimmer of the Year | Trinity Heath | Roosevelt | |
| Diver of the Year | Ella Houk | Roosevelt |
2nd Team All League
| Natalie St. John | Kent |
| Emmy Schmidt | Revere |
| Carley Schreiber | Highland |
| Keira Hilton | Kent |
| Grace Nessel | Aurora |
| Anna Eisentraut | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Hannah Rapko | Aurora |
| Annastassia Koval | Highland |
| Rachel Tan | Tallmadge |
| Emery Banks | Revere |
| Grace Whitestine | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Melissa Durny | Highland |
| Allison Finnegan | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Maryn Matolyak | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Hanna Mosier | Copley |
| Cassidy Singer | Kent |
Honorable Mention
| Aurora | Alexandra Yuhasz | ||
| Aurora | Katie Hunter | ||
| Barberton | Hannah Swanson | ||
| Barberton | Jenna Matheson | ||
| Copley | Hannah Powell | ||
| Copley | Clare Yoder | ||
| Cuyahoga Falls | Kate McDaniels | ||
| Cuyahoga Falls | Sophia Gonzalez | ||
| Highland | Allyson Ringgenberg | ||
| Highland | Emma Osborne | ||
| Kent | Madolyn Kost | ||
| Kent | Ellie Amodio | ||
| Revere | Kajsa Martynyuk | ||
| Revere | Carlee Coleman | ||
| Tallmadge | Elliott Neupert | ||
| Tallmadge | Becca Riter |