1st Team All League
| Rayna Unverferth | Aurora |
| Sophie Petrash | Aurora |
| Sophia Schechterman | Aurora |
| Leila Staszak | Tallmadge |
| Danielle Charton | Tallmadge |
| Kate Muri | Highland |
| Elsa Riedy | Highland |
| Jayce Collins | Copley |
| Caroline Deagan | Copley |
| Alexa Kelley | Revere |
| Ashley Gardner | Revere |
| Madi Davis | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Avery Gates | Roosevelt |
| Cassie Moore | Barberton |
| Coach of Year | Sam Petrash | Aurora |
| Co-Player of the Year | Lailah Bohanan | Aurora |
| Co-Player of the Year | Paige Kelley | Revere |
| Pitcher of the Year | Sophie Retton | Aurora |
2nd Team All League
| Lila Bultrowicz | Aurora |
| Julia Miller | Aurora |
| Avery Qualters | Aurora |
| Gayle Mishic | Revere |
| Sydney Kreighbaum | Revere |
| Katie Huth | Tallmadge |
| Payton Almond | Tallmadge |
| Addy Stewart | Copley |
| Allison Martz | Copley |
| Alexis Mutch | Highland |
| Lilly Horton | Highland |
| Kellcie Mastrododonato | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Devin Stohovitch | Roosevelt |
| Natalie Snider | Barberton |
Honorable Mention
| Charlotte Sorma | Aurora |
| Alexis Kemble | Aurora |
| Mattie Diaz | Revere |
| Tess Hodgen | Revere |
| Kiley Martin | Highland |
| Arisa Murray | Highland |
| Larissa Taylor | Tallmadge |
| Naomi Richardson | Tallmadge |
| Carmen Cunat | Copley |
| Stella Kaplack | Copley |
| Skylar Lauck | Roosevelt |
| Kamia Green | Roosevelt |
| Elizabeth Scott | Barberton |
| Layla Murrey | Barberton |
| Mackenzie Miller | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Ava Waite | Cuyahoga Falls |